Turf Wars heat up at Talking Stick Golf Club, where O’Odham’s desert strategy battles Piipaash’s parkland precision. A personal favorite since 2004, let’s settle the score.
WellVision Plus by WellPutt
Sharpen your putting precision like never before with Wellvision Plus, the ultimate dual-mirror training system trusted by Tour players worldwide to refine their setup and stroke. Engineered with an ultra-thin, black stainless steel design (just 0.03 inches, the thinnest on the market!). It delivers a precision training experience that fits seamlessly on any surface.
The primary mirror provides visual feedback to confirm proper eye position.
The secondary mirror provides visual feedback to confirm proper shoulder and body position.
The adjustable start line gate allows you to check your ability to send the ball along your intended start line.
The adjustable putter head gate helps you train for solid ball contact.
Talking Stick Golf Club
Bunkers, green speeds, and signature holes. Two Valley icons enter, but only one can claim your Saturday morning tee time.
We head to one of Scottsdale’s most iconic 36-hole setups, Talking Stick Golf Club, for a sibling rivalry years in the making.
In the northern corner, the O’Odham Course: a wide-open, wind-kissed links-style layout that rewards the strategic golfer.
In the southern corner, the Piipaash Course: a parkland-style track packed with water hazards, mature trees, and straight-up shotmaking challenges.
I’ve walked both more times than I can count, but I still remember the first time. The Scottsdale City Boys Championship in 2004, when my high school team took home the title. Walking these fairways still brings back that memory.
Do you think Arizona golf courses should implement a discounted resident rate to offset the increase in green fees?
Round 1: First Impressions (Arrival + Vibe)
Talking Stick sets the tone early: the largest public practice facility in the valley, a remodeled clubhouse, and views for days.
O’Odham welcomes you with a minimalist, links-inspired layout. Think subtle contours and a sense of “The Open” played in Scottsdale. It’s raw and clean, like golf stripped down.
Piipaash counters with eucalyptus-lined fairways and visible water hazards. It’s more traditional and polished than a punch in the face (in a good way).
“O’Odham feels like strategy. Piipaash feels like survival.”
Verdict:
O’Odham brings soul. Piipaash brings tradition.
Round 2: Layout + Shot Value
O’Odham (par 70, 7,133 yards): Wide fairways. No water. Crowned greens. It’s cerebral. Miss on the wrong side and you’re toast. Angles are everything.
Piipaash (par 71, 6,833 yards): Narrower corridors. More hazards. Three beastly par-5s. It’s less about geometry, more about guts.
Coore and Crenshaw designed both, but they play like rivals.
“These are desert siblings, but they don’t play nice.”
Verdict:
O’Odham, if you like to think. Piipaash, if you like to swing.
Round 3: Course Conditions
Both are managed by Arnold Palmer Golf Management, which means:
Fairways = firm, lush, consistent.
Greens = MiniVerde Bermuda, quick and pure.
Bunkers = maintained like a tour event.
O’Odham’s greens are subtle and fast. Piipaash are more elevated and guarded. Both hold up through 85,000+ rounds a year, which is wild.
Verdict:
Draw. You won’t blame your score on the turf.
1 & 2 @ O’Odham
Round 4: Difficulty + Scoring
O’Odham is deceptively forgiving off the tee, but it’s sneaky hard if you chase birdies. Bogey golf lives happily here. Birdie golf? Gotta earn it.
Piipaash, on the other hand, shows you its teeth: narrower, wetter, tighter. One big miss, and you’re reloading. But if you’re flushing it, the layout rewards confidence.
Verdict:
High-handicapper? O’Odham is kinder.
Low-handicapper? Piipaash might be your playground.
18 @ Piipaash
Round 5: Intangibles
Both courses are on sacred tribal land. Their names honor the O’odham and Piipaash peoples. There’s history here, and it shows.
Wild horses roam the fairways. Coyotes spectate from the edges. It’s golf on native land, with nature leaning in.
Verdict:
O’Odham has mystique. Piipaash has swag.
Winner’s Circle: My Pick
Winner: O’Odham
The creativity, subtlety, and strategic depth are just glorious. It’ll challenge everything you think you know about desert golf if you've never played it.
More Turf Wars:
News
Charlie Woods punches his ticket to the U.S. Junior Amateur, surviving a tense 3-for-1 playoff while Tiger watches his son deliver under pressure. (more)
Equipment
A classic blade reborn, the Titleist 680 MB offers a traditional profile, thin topline, added bounce, and elite precision for shotmakers who crave total control. (more)
Fashion
Golf trips are all fun and fairways until travel day chaos hits. Here’s how to prep like a pro and avoid rookie mistakes before the first tee. (more)
Seeking impartial news? Meet 1440.
Every day, 3.5 million readers turn to 1440 for their factual news. We sift through 100+ sources to bring you a complete summary of politics, global events, business, and culture, all in a brief 5-minute email. Enjoy an impartial news experience.
News
Quintero Golf Club begins a $7M renovation this summer, rebuilding greens, tees, and bunkers. Arizona’s top public course will reopen in October, refreshed and ready for tournaments. (more)
Red Lawrence’s 1962 masterpiece, Desert Forest, redefined desert golf. A minimalist marvel, it honors tradition while pioneering design, quietly standing as Arizona’s most underrated classic. (more)
Events
Play with legends. Win epic prizes. The Crystal Cup pairs elite amateurs with Luke & Lexi across top Troon courses, ending in a Sea Island showdown. (more)
Desert Mountain Club will host the 2026 U.S. Amateur Four-Ball and 2029 U.S. Women’s Four-Ball, Arizona’s first time staging both prestigious USGA team championships. (more)
How did you like today's newsletter?
New here?
Download over 150 course reviews: A Review of Every Course I’ve Played
